How many of us appreciate being criticized for our work?

One of the best lessons I have learned through my postgraduate years is to be able to absorb criticism and feedback and appreciate the positive side of it. I did not always have this appreciation; it did not start out as a positive adventure at all. I started out as a naïve and afraid student and received detailed feedback thinking that maybe people did not like me or that they wanted to prove that I am not intelligent.

Fortunately, I had supervisors during my Masters who honed my presentation skills and removed my ‘stage fright’ by allowing me to attend many conferences and symposiums. During this time, I learned a lot about myself and how feedback improved my academic skills. I remember the first time we had our presentation in the Polymer/Organic group, one of our senior postgraduate students was presenting and the supervisors were very critical, and I thought to myself ‘I hope when my turn comes, I do not cry’.  As weeks went by, I realized that the supervisors were hard on all of us, not just on one person, and that is when I realized that it is to train us and not belittle us. Today, when I give a presentation and I am not criticized or asked the hard questions, I know that people did not comprehend what I said, or it was not interesting enough for them to think critically about it.

One of the most discouraging things is to receive negative feedback for a paper that you are trying to publish. Most of us in academia have experienced this. Before the submission, there is a lot of pressure from yourself or from your supervisors and peers. Then unfortunately you often get negative feedback from the reviewers. How does one even overcome that? The first rejections may be a large blow, but the reality is there might be several rejections before the article is accepted for publication.

I had a conversation with one of my friends earlier this year, whose paper had been rejected three times and from these conversations, I learned a few things.

  • The rejections normally come with comments which help one to write or present better.
  • Their rejection is not a reflection of who you are or the type of person you are, it is purely commentary on a piece of written work
  • Dust yourself up, cry if you have to, and do it all over again. Send it to another journal, and put your work out.
  • The more you get rejected the better you get at writing and improving your work.
  • You learn and read from the comments articulated in each section.

This also happens when we are doing writing outside of the scientific space. A few months ago, I submitted a blog to our editor Jen. I had read articles on what I had written and thought I had done very well. Just a few days after submission I received feedback from her. I was on my way to heat food in the microwave when I heard a beep on my phone, I scanned the message and I panicked. The 30 seconds I heated the food, thoughts flooded my mind, ‘does she not like me, does she think I’m a bad writer, she doesn’t find me worthy does she?’ I then sat myself down and calmed myself to look at the piece critically. I felt disappointed in myself for thinking in my moment of panic that she hated me because, with the reviews she gave, she also advised, she showed me the way and I am thankful for that. And with the corrected piece I could see my improvement. One of the messages she gave was, ‘The best way to start writing on scientific topics is to work from your area of expertise.’ I will take that forever because when I did write my next piece, it came out of passion and was easier to write.

We just need to learn to stop over-personalizing the critiques and find what is good in them. I am not saying I am immune to being criticized, but I appreciate being assisted and being told if I am wrong or redirected to the right path. Maybe our rationality is thwarted by our emotions. When we hear criticism, our instinct is to dismiss it. Then, we put up a defense and sometimes even get irritated. Although this is understandable, it works against us. Everything that benefits us should be embraced, rationally speaking.

‘He who can’t take constructive criticism is not ready to grow’- Royalelradin

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s